Coleman tailgate grill vs. Weber tailgate grill: Which is best for your party?

Camp Cooking

Important safety note: Portable grills might be small and easy to move, but never use them indoors. Grills give off carbon monoxide, which is odorless, invisible and potentially lethal.

BestReviews is reader-supported and may earn an affiliate commission. Details.

Which Coleman or Weber tailgate grill is best? 

What tailgating party is complete without a portable grill for cooking up your favorite hamburgers, hotdogs and other delicious foods for your friends and family? It can be difficult to decide which portable grill is best for your specific needs. 

Coleman and Weber are both outdoor brand giants. Coleman has 120 years of providing trusted outdoor equipment, including grills, and Weber is also a longtime, respected grill maker that hails from the 1950s. For more information on portable grills, check out the BestReviews buying guide. 

What should I look for in a portable grill?

Fuel type

You can choose charcoal, propane gas or liquid propane. Although propane is more commonly used, charcoal is preferred by many grilling experts. 

Size

Consider the size and weight, and check the dimensions to make sure it’ll fit in your vehicle and can be easily transported to your tailgating location.

Grill area

Look at the dimensions of the grill area given in square inches. If you’re cooking for a large crowd, you’ll want more grill space to feed more people at a time.

Performance

For grills, power is given in British Thermal Units (BTU). Experts suggest you should have more than 50 BTU per square inch to get a good sear. 

Coleman grills

Coleman is a longtime manufacturer of outdoor equipment, including lighting, tents, coolers and grills, and aims to meet people wherever there are friends, coolers and campfires. During World War II, Coleman helped soldiers eat hot meals with its camp stoves, and it launched its portable RoadTrip Grill in 2003.

Coleman grills are all compact. The Fold N Go design weighs just 10 pounds and fits in a backpack. The RoadTrip models weigh 50 pounds and fold down to easily fit in a trunk.

How much does a Coleman grill cost?

Coleman grills are quite affordable. The propane Fold N Go models start at just $50, and the larger tabletop models are around $100. Their mid-range Sport is about $175, while the top-of-the-line RoadTrip LXE is only $400.

Coleman grill pros

  • Offers compact, easily portable Fold N Go models.
  • Have removable grates for griddle or stove inserts.
  • Often has easy push-button ignition.
  • Uses a 16 ounce propane bottle, enough to fuel most grills.

Coleman grill cons

  • Less durable construction.
  • The company doesn’t provide replacement parts.
  • Some models don’t include tools or accessories.

Best mini Coleman grill for tailgating

Coleman RoadTrip Party Grill

Coleman RoadTrip Party Grill

If you want a small, round, propane grill similar to a Weber charcoal grill for under $60, this is your best bet. This 6 pound model offers push-button electronic ignition, even temperatures and detachable legs. This model doesn’t include a propane tank, lid or bag. 

Sold by Amazon, Dick’s Sporting Goods, Home Depot and Kohl’s

Best bang for the buck Coleman grill for tailgating

Coleman Fold N Go Propane Grill

Coleman Fold N Go Propane Grill

This portable folding grill has a horseshoe-like design (14 inches by 16 inches), a built-in handle and covers 105 square inches. It delivers 6,000 BTUs of heat and has a removable dishwasher-safe cooking surface and grease tray for easy cleaning. 

Sold by Amazon

Best overall Coleman grill for tailgating

Coleman Gas Camping Grill/Stove

Coleman Gas Camping Grill/Stove

This model allows you to grill and use the stove at the same time, offers 130 square inches of grilling area and fits a 10 inch pan. It’s powerful with up to 20,000 total BTUs, more efficient cooking with less fuel, pressure-control technology and two adjustable burners. 

Sold by Amazon

Best of the best Coleman grill for tailgating

Coleman RoadTrip Sport Propane Grill

Coleman RoadTrip Sport Propane Grill

This lightweight, durable and easy-to-transport model offers a large 225 square-inch cooking surface with porcelain-coated grates for easy clean-up. It’s made to be used with a 16 ounce propane cylinder. 

Sold by Amazon

Weber grills

A specialty maker of charcoal, gas, electric and portable grills, Weber was built on the belief that there is nothing better than enjoying a delicious meal outside with the ones you love. In 1952, Weber’s founder devised a new grill design inspired by a buoy’s shape, which incited excitement about kettle grills and kicked off the world’s leading barbecue brand.

Trying to choose a Weber grill can get complicated, because the company offers so many models. You also have to consider the size, fuel, grate and other features. 

How much does a Weber grill cost?

Weber portable grills range in size from 145 to 240 square inches and usually cost between $35-$70. A small charcoal grill usually costs between $90-$400.

Weber grill pros

  • High-quality construction.
  • Many models have an easy push-start ignition.
  • Larger models have nice built-in features, like thermometers.
  • Replacement parts are available.

Weber grill cons

  • More expensive.
  • Decision fatigue from so many models.
  • Charcoal grills have less cooking area and fewer features.

Best Weber grill for tailgating

Best mini Weber propane portable grill

Weber Go-Anywhere Gas Grill

Weber Go-Anywhere Gas Grill

This model features a push-button igniter, a porcelain-enameled grate and 160 square inches of cooking space. Its steel legs pivot to lock in place, and it uses a 14.1 ounce propane tank. 

Sold by Amazon, Dick’s Sporting Goods and Home Depot

Best bang for the buck Weber portable grill

Weber Jumbo Joe 18-inch Charcoal Grill

Weber Jumbo Joe 18-inch Charcoal Grill

This deep tabletop grill is an excellent choice: lightweight and compact, with a larger grilling area that holds up to eight burgers and a convenient carry handle. The porcelain-enameled lid and bowl retain heat and won’t rust or peel, and the Tuck-N-Carry lid lock doubles as a lid holder. 

Sold by Amazon

Best overall Weber grill

Weber Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill 

Weber Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill 

This light and sturdy grill is easy to carry and assemble, offers 189 square inches of grill space (enough to hold 15 burgers) and gets up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit after only 15 minutes with the lid closed. It has flare-out trays to hold plates and tools and comes in many fun colors. 

Sold by Amazon and Home Depot 

Best of the best Weber grill

Weber Q2200 1-Burner Portable Liquid Propane Grill 

Weber Q2200 1-Burner Portable Liquid Propane Grill 

This lovely model offers 280 square inches of cooking area with a 12,000 BTU-per-hour stainless steel burner. It has porcelain-enameled, cast-iron cooking grates, electronic ignition with a built-in thermometer and two folding working tables. 

Sold by Amazon, Dick’s Sporting Goods and Home Depot

Should you get a Coleman or Weber grill for tailgating?

Overall, Weber grills are more expensive than Coleman grills, but since Weber specializes in grills, that’s to be expected. If you’re on a budget, Coleman grills are probably your best bet. If you’re willing to pay a bit more for high-quality construction and features, Weber is the grill for you.

For more on Coleman grills and Weber grills, check out BestReviews’ guides.

 

Sign up here to receive the BestReviews weekly newsletter for useful advice on new products and noteworthy deals.

Jane VanVooren Rogers writes for BestReviews. BestReviews has helped millions of consumers simplify their purchasing decisions, saving them time and money.

Copyright 2021 BestReviews, a Nexstar company. All rights reserved.