Which mattress protectors are best?
A quality mattress is a significant purchase, so it’s natural that you’d want to keep it as clean and fresh as possible to help it last longer. A mattress protector can block dust mites, stop allergens (such as pollen, mold, and mildew) from settling into your mattress, and prevent liquids from reaching the mattress.
Mattress protectors vary in their breathability, waterproofing, materials, and other factors. In addition, they are designed to fit different mattress styles, so finding the model that works for your needs and your mattress is crucial.
Read on to learn how to select the best mattress protector for you. Our favorite option is the SureGuard Mattress Protector, a soft, comfortable, and noiseless waterproof mattress protector with a cotton terry top layer.
What to know before you buy a mattress protector
Some mattress protectors are waterproof and some are not, but what are the benefits and downfalls of each type?
Waterproof mattress protectors keep all kinds of fluids away from your mattress, such as spilled drinks, sweat, and urine. They’re particularly useful for children who aren’t yet reliably dry through the night or anyone with incontinence issues. However, they generally provide some of the best mattress protection, even if bedwetting isn’t a problem in your household. The trouble is that they can make a rustling sound when you move and they may feel hot to sleep on because of the waterproof layer.
Non-waterproof mattress protectors can absorb some nighttime sweat, prevent allergens from entering your mattress, and help slow down general wear and tear. Many are lightly padded to provide some extra comfort and they tend to be relatively breathable. Of course, they’re not going to keep your mattress safe from any significant volume of fluid.
The outer layer of a mattress protector is usually either made from cotton, polyester, or a cotton/poly blend. Of these materials, cotton is the most breathable and is the best choice to avoid sleeping hot.
The waterproof layer of some mattress protectors is most often made of polyurethane, since it retains some degree of breathability and isn’t too noisy. PVC and vinyl are hotter to sleep on and make more noise but are more reliably waterproof when confronted with large volumes of liquid.
What to look for in a quality mattress protector
One of the great benefits of mattress protectors is that they can block allergens such as dust, pet dander, pollen, mold, and mildew from getting inside a mattress. These allergens may get trapped in the mattress protector but will wash away when you clean it.
The vast majority of mattress protectors fit on a mattress in the same way as a fitted sheet, but some models completely enclose your mattress. While these are more challenging to get on, they provide a more secure fit.
Be sure to purchase a mattress protector designed for your type of mattress. Otherwise, you may end up with excess material or not enough coverage — or the protector may not fit on your mattress at all.
How much you can expect to spend on a mattress protector
Mattress protectors can cost anywhere between $10-$100, depending on the design, size, and overall quality.
Mattress protectors FAQ
Q. I don’t think I sweat much at night. Do I need a waterproof mattress protector?
A. Even if you don’t feel as though you sweat much in the night, you’ll still be losing a small amount of liquid through perspiration. Spilled beverages can also be an issue, and if you suffer from incontinence, a waterproof mattress protector can make cleanup easy and can keep your mattress looking pristine.
Q. Do mattress protectors feel hot to sleep on?
A. Some mattress protectors do feel hot to sleep on, but this depends on the materials they’re made from. A decent mattress should have some degree of breathability to allow airflow while you sleep, but when you put a mattress protector on top that’s made from non-breathable materials, more of your body heat will get trapped in bed with you. If you tend to sleep hot at night or are concerned about feeling too warm with the addition of a mattress protector, choose a model made from breathable materials.
What are the best mattress protectors to buy?
Top mattress protector
Our take: This mattress protector feels soft and doesn’t rustle as you move.
What we like: The cotton terry outer layer wicks away moisture. Uses a breathable membrane. Anti-allergen protection.
What we dislike: Some buyers say it isn’t waterproof enough to deal with bedwetting.
Where to buy: Sold by Amazon
Top mattress protector for the money
Our take: A versatile and affordable option available in many different sizes.
What we like: Protects against dust mites, fluids and more. This protector is waterproof yet breathable. Cotton terry top helps sheets stay dry-feeling.
What we dislike: Advertised as noiseless, but there are some reports of crinkling, especially when new.
Where to buy: Sold by Amazon
Worth checking out
Our take: Luna Airflow Technology allows air to flow through the waterproof membrane while blocking liquid getting through.
What we like: Hypoallergenic design. Cotton terry upper layer. Fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. Comes with a 15 year warranty. Made in the U.S.
What we dislike: Can feel hot to sleep on despite claims of breathability.
Where to buy: Sold by Amazon
Sign up here to receive the BestReviews weekly newsletter for useful advice on new products and noteworthy deals.
Lauren Corona writes for BestReviews. BestReviews has helped millions of consumers simplify their purchasing decisions, saving them time and money.
Copyright 2021 BestReviews, a Nexstar company. All rights reserved.