Denver woman accused of repeatedly stealing person’s identity

Problem Solvers
This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

GOLDEN, Colo. — Jenell Mejia dreads opening her own mail. For the past six months, she’s been inundated by unpleasant surprises: overdue bills, court summonses, threats to suspend her driver license and letters from various government agencies, including criminal prosecutors.

Her name is on the documents, but the rest of the contents are entirely unfamiliar.

Mejia is a victim of identity theft and fraud, one of the most common crimes in Colorado. In fact, she’s the perfect victim: she has good credit and no criminal record.

Mejia had her identification stolen during a car break-in two years ago. Then, last August, Mejia received a call from Lakewood police.

They had arrested a woman at the Colorado Mills Mall who said her name was Jenell Mejia. According to the police report reviewed by FOX31, the accused shoplifter even verbally gave an officer Mejia’s correct date of birth.

Mall security inside the Calvin Klein store had spotted a woman “selecting items and placing them into her brown purse.”

Records show that when confronted, the suspect tried “running” and “continued to struggle” while a uniformed Lakewood officer put handcuffs on her.

Mejia’s phone rang. It was a police officer.

“She asked, ‘Are you Jenell?’ I said, ‘Yes.’ ‘We have someone here who was caught shoplifting and trying to use your name. They misspelled it. That’s when I decided to look up in the system and saw it was not you.'” Mejia told FOX31.

Mejia went down to the mall and reviewed security footage of the shoplifter and didn’t recognize her.

At the jail, the shoplifter’s story came apart once fingerprints revealed her true identity.

Her name was Amanda Jo Garcia. Jefferson County prosecutors filed charges against the 31-year-old Denver resident for theft, resisting arrest and criminal impersonation.

Garcia’s Colorado Bureau of Investigations crime sheet shows she’s been charged with at least 80 various crimes and offenses over the years.

“I’m not related. I don’t know who this person is!” Mejia told the FOX31 Problem Solvers. “I’m obviously not the one who did anything. I’m just out to protecting myself because I’m not going to take fault for something I didn’t do and I’m sure as hell not going to let someone do that to me. I’m going to go until I get my name cleared.”

But getting her name cleared has been a nightmare.  The accused criminal’s police stops have started getting mixed up with the records of the innocent victim.

FOX31 discovered Garcia was pulled over by Denver police for speeding after posting bond on the Colorado Mills Mall incident. However, Mejia is the one who received the ticket because Denver detectives now believe Garcia lied to the traffic officer while impersonating Mejia. That realization didn’t occur until after a judge ordered Mejia into court and the Division of Motor Vehicles issued a suspension of license notice to Mejia for not showing up to pay “her” speeding fine.

And around Thanksgiving, Garcia was arrested by Lone Tree police – again for alleged shoplifting.


Garcia had Mejia’s ID card in her pocket.

Garcia showed up in Jefferson County court earlier this week for a criminal arraignment. Afterwards, the FOX31 Problem Solvers approached her to ask about her pretending to be Mejia when stopped by police.

Garcia denied everything.

FOX31: “When you get stopped by police and pretend to be somebody else, it’s a really serious accusation.”

Garcia: “It’s not. It’s not ‘cause I never got stopped by police, so I don’t know what to tell you.”

FOX31: “You were pretending to be somebody else?”

Garcia: “Nope. Sure wasn’t.”

FOX31: “You know, it hurts this other person’s reputation for you to do that.”

Garcia:  “What the f***. It’s all false accusations.”

If you need help dealing with an identify theft, the Colorado Bureau of Investigation’s identity theft and fraud/cyber crime unit can help. Email or call the 24-hour ID Theft Hotline: 1-855-443-3489.

Most Read

Top Stories

More Home Page Top Stories